All Stars 8
Not everything went wrong with this All Stars outing — but most everything did.
All Stars 9
Baby, you can’t read the doll! But you can critique a too-lengthy non-elimination season.
This notoriously awful season has fully earned that reputation.
One of the all-time great seasons saved the All Stars format.
It starts strong, but there’s no saving All Stars 3 from the jury twist.
Some of the most legendary moments come out of this season.
The top three is great, but getting to the end is a formality.
The best All Stars season in years came at just the right time.
Not everything went wrong with this All Stars outing — but most everything did.
Baby, you can’t read the doll! But you can critique a too-lengthy non-elimination season.
The Tournament of All Stars launched with a bang — and landed with a thud.
How did a second run of the Tournament of All Stars improve upon the first?