All Stars 3
It starts strong, but there’s no saving All Stars 3 from the jury twist.
Can a season be more than its finale? That’s the question that plagues All Stars 3, which has some great episodes (in particular “The Bitchelor”) and moments (Jungle Kitty!), but largely falters thanks to its jury twist. Letting the eliminated queens vote on which two finalists should move on to lip sync for the win effectively guaranteed a Trixie Mattel victory. Truth be told, the season had problems before, including a terrible top five acting challenge and BenDeLaCreme’s choice to quit rather than complete the season. But the jury twist was a bridge too far, and sunk All Stars 3 to the bottom half of many a fan’s season rankings.